Categories: News

Council Schedules Meeting: On Coughlin Park Renovations

Dawn Manning speaks at Tuesday’s
Town Council meeting.

The Winthrop Town Council voted unanimously to arrange a meeting with Point Shirley residents to discuss the ongoing renovations at Coughlin Park and public safety concerns at the park.

Councilor James Letterie made the motion to schedule the meeting at the Point Shirley Association following a discussion of the Coughlin Park renovations and increased traffic and resident parking issues during the public comment period of the Council meeting.  Town Manager James McKenna will set up the meeting to which Department of Public Works Steve  Calla and Director of Parks and Recreation Sean Driscoll will be invited to meet with the residents.  Point Shirley resident Jane Poe requested the public meeting, saying that she had a petition signed by more than 100 residents, citing the “real and immediate concern relative to the use of Coughlin Playground for organized sports and the negative impact on the quality of life for residents” in the area. Poe later thanked Letterie for reacting swiftly to the residents’ request for a meeting.

Council President Peter Gill’s decision not to reappoint Dawn Manning to a second term on the town’s Park Committee drew exchanges at the meeting. Manning, a charter member of the committee that was originated by Gill to contribute ideas for the renovations at Winthrop parks, addressed the issue in the public comment portion of the meeting. Manning’s husband, Keith, expressed dismay at his wife not being  reappointed to the committee, praising her previous work on the committee.

Gill appointed Meredith Hurley and Julie Swanson as new members of the five-person parks committee. Former member Barbara Duffy had resigned from the committee, creating a second vacancy on the board. The other members are chair Linda Bressard, Dawn Sullivan, and Carlos Broussard. Councilor Linda Calla seemed to question Gill’s decision during the second public comment period at the end of the meeting.

“We had a young woman here tonight that is very energetic and she’s very passionate about the parks,” said Calla. “She has a proven track record that she has raised a lot of money. Why wouldn’t we want to have her on that [parks] committee? Even if it was in an alternate position – there a lot of times when people can’t make the meetings, if you have another person, they may be available in bringing up ideas or they may needed for some kind of vote or maybe to get out there and make some calls.”
Calla said, “it seems like she [Dawn Manning] was overlooked, passed over. For whatever reason it happened, I have no idea, but that really doesn’t send a good message to somebody who really wants to volunteer.”

Gill responded, “The council president has the responsibilities to make the choices and appointments that he thinks are the most appropriate. I will not get into discussing personalities.” Calla asked that consideration be given to the appointment of alternate members, but Gill said his decision was to have five members of the committee and no alternates.

Cary Shuman

View Comments

  • It seems that even Town Council presdient Peter Gill backed off and decided maybe it was a good idea to allow Point Shirley residents to discuss a park that has been in their neighbhood for decades. Well, that was nice of him, after he banned from the August 19th meeting Tom McNiff, a Point Shirley resident who broke open the discussion before Mrs. Poe had a chance to submit her petitions.

    Gill seemed to not like being questioned and then requestioned by McNiff who asserted that Gill did not reply to questions about a parks meeting and also why Gill did not have the courtesy to reply to the queries. Gill began some sort of dither that the state Open Meeing Law prohibited him from answering questions, presumably during the public comment of a council session. McNiff objected to that excuse. Gill accused McNiff of interrupting him five times, to which McNiff replied, "make it six".

    Out was a flabbergasted Gill's response.

    This whole fiasco would not have happened had Gill exercised a little judgement, saying as questions were asked about a meeting that the matter would be taken up that same evening. And he would not have looked a bit dictatorial had he just not seen the situation as his authority being challenged. By McNiff's second request to speak during the first public comment period, it was very obvious - especially from Mrs. Poe's petitions submissions - that the Point Shirley issue was an important one that people in attendance were not likely to sit back and ignore. Gill's excuses were soon swept under a rug as other councilors Town Manager James McKenna took up the issue.

    Gill started the evening trying to assert his authority when another often critical town resident brought up the topic of the state Open Meeting Law and charged that Winthrop's Town Council often violates that statutute. Gill got into a shouting match with the speaker and tossed him out too.

    The Transcript apparently made an editorial decision to not include the episodes of two town residents being tossed out by the Town Council president without asking if either of the men would mind such coverage.

    Tom McNiff
    Precinct 3

  • LOL. You Winthropites are crazy. Here are the headlines from your meeting:

    100 town members sign a petition to stop allowing people to use a park as....a park.

    Woman shows up to town council meeting to bully her way back on to committee. Shocked she wasn't reappointed in the first place...

    The Onion would love your town.

Recent Posts

St. John’s Episcopal Church Spring Craft Fair

Luca DePhamphillis, 7, with his nina, Pam Evans, hooking a Charmander Pokémon necklace around her…

5 days ago

Lieutenant Lessard Remembered for His Caring and Department Initiatives

Retired Winthrop Police Lt. David Lessard, 69 died last Friday after a long battle with…

5 days ago

Marino Looks to Possible Debt Exclusion for School Budget Needs

By Adam Swift The town is looking toward a possible debt exclusion vote in the…

5 days ago

Town Manager Presents Capital Plan at Spring Forum

By Adam Swift As part of the Annual Spring Forum on Tuesday night, Town Manager…

5 days ago

News Brief

Winthrop Police Department Awarded Car Seat Distribution Grant  Police Chief John Goodwin is pleased to…

5 days ago

State and City Officials Meet With La Colaborativa on Shelter Operation Plans in Chelsea

By Adam Swift State and Chelsea officials, along with local nonprofit La Colaborativa, have spent…

5 days ago